To sell old coins, take low and medium-value coins to a reputable coin dealer, where you should be able to easily sell them. If you can't find a local coin dealer, try. Our coins price guide has values for old & rare United States coins. We actively buy and sell coins. Contact us to find out what your coin is worth today. Selling Old Coins and Currency The Easy Way · 1. Order free selling pack. We post you a full product guide and free pre-paid postage labels. · 2. Collection or drop. Please note: We do not charge for any of the services mentioned above and there is no obligation to sell after obtaining a free valuation. Buyers may also be reluctant to pay a premium for an item they have been unable to inspect at first hand. Consult a numismatic expert and, if appropriate, they will clean the coin on your behalf. It is not unusual for collectors to over value coins in their possession, where can i sell old coins unfortunately, some people also under value what are actually truly rare coins. Our coin value guide has pictures and prices for thousands of rare U. Apmex Well known.