The top 5 most valuable united states coins · Liberty Head Nickel · Silver Dollar · Double Eagle (D) · Silver Dollar · Half. Top 10 Most Valuable U.S. Coins Found in Pocket Change · Lincoln Cent With a Doubled Die Obverse · Wide "AM" Reverse Lincoln. THE TOP 5 MOST VALUABLE UNITED STATES COINS · Liberty Head Nickel · Silver Dollar · Double Eagle (D) · Silver Dollar. Specimens are still being found in circulation all the time! Another way to identify the Small Date variety is to look at the 7 in the date. Coin collectors have managed to preserve this historic and highly valuable coin for more than years, which adds even more value to the coins story and price tag. The coin is made of In some cases, it is most expensive us coin entirely.