These homemade chocolate coins are much easier to make than you probably think. They take just a few ingredients and a little bit of time! Homemade Chocolate Coins · Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Set aside. · Over a double boiler, stir the chocolate until melted. · Make. Make your own organic chocolate coins that look just like the store bought gold chocolate coins! No sugar and can be all natural or organic! I went into the grocery store having a few toppings in mind, and walked out with way more. Learn More. So when my 3 year old son asked for gold chocolate coins for Christmas this year I knew I needed to find a way to make it happen while staying within our low-sugar, organic food choices. Some more topping ideas:. How to Make Gold Chocolate Coins, Organic and No Sugar I've used it making chocolate coins many things in the pastand once again, the making chocolate coins sweetened chocolate recipe came to the rescue! Drop a spoonful of melted chocolate into 24 mini muffin cavities.