We do our best to provide precise spot prices; however, during times of market volatility, prices may not be to-the-minute accurate. PCGS logo reversed. 5 reviews of Hartville Coin & Jewelry - CLOSED "I like this store for a few reasons, but the first is the prices. 8 documented times thieves came to read more. Get directions, reviews and information for Hartville Coin & Jewelry in Hartville, OH. Opening Hours. Mon: 9am-6pm; Tue: 10am-5pm; Wed: 10am-5pm; Thu.